Miko Marks Wins San Francisco Journal’s Hardly Strictly Bluegrass Dolly Parton Award

Miko Marks rendition of Dolly Parton’s I’ll Always Love You has been select as the San Francisco Journal’s Hardly Strictly Bluegrass Dolly Parton Award. Congratulations!

During the festival, many acts paid tribute to Dolly Parton who passed away this year. I have never been a big Country Music fan, save for a few artists and Dolly was never on that list but Dolly sure did have a lot of fans. Miko Marks did an incredible interpretation of I’ll Always Love You.. The chords are different. The melody is different. The words and message are the same.

“I Will Always Love You” is a song written and originally recorded in 1973 by American singer-songwriter Dolly Parton. Written as a farewell to her business partner and mentor Porter Wagoner, expressing Parton’s gratitude and also her decision to pursue a solo career,[1] the country single was released in 1974. The song was a commercial success for Parton, twice reaching the top spot of the US Billboard Hot Country Songs chart: first in June 1974, then again in October 1982, with a re-recording for The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas soundtrack.
– Wikipedia

Miko Marks has an interesting musical story. Getting into the music business later in life, she started gigging in middle age. She embraces her family history in the west. You can read more about it at https://oaklandbca.org/

It is one of those seldom-told stories, about how African Americans are an integral story to the west. Out on the lonely plains and in the mountains more often than not many Black folk were embraced as part of the settler communities once white folk realized that their Black neighbors were indispensable to the community’s survival. For instance, A Black Woman’s West: The Life of Rose B. Gordon by Michael K. Johnson chronicles Rose B. Gordon’s life in small town Montana. There are surely many more similar stories that have never made it to print.

It is fascinating how the musical landscape of places in the twentieth century were surely formed by the radio people heard. When you lived out in the country you surely heard Country Music on your transistor radio. It is not surprising that a Black women would be influenced and a fan of the music of Dolly Parton. Ray Charles has a similar story.

I was unable to find a studio version of Dolly Parton’s I’ll Always Love You by Miko Marks. It is simply brilliant and will surely live on.

Hardly Strictly Festival 2026 Awards

Hardly Strictly Bluegrass 2026 took place in Golden Gate Park on Fri, Oct 2, 2026 – Sun, Oct 4, 2026. It is a free event. You can learn more about it at https://hardlystrictlybluegrass.com/.

The weather during the festival in 2026 was superb. For all the days the wind was light out of the west. On Saturday it was even hot and sunny getting up to the high-eighties. Many people did retreat to the shade by the trees. Come Sunday some high clouds moved in, it got cooler and the temperatures dropped.

There are basically two approaches to HSB. One is to travel light and get in as many acts in as possible, roaming from one stage to the next. The other is to bring a tarp or blankets, chairs and a small cooler full of food and drinks and park at a single stage. If you get to the festival early, it is easy to get a great spot. This year we did a bit of both. On Friday we parked at first at the Banjo Stage and enjoyed the mostly country music.  My buddy Steve was in town and we went all three days. It’s a pretty amazing free festival.

SHOWS ATTENDED

FRIDAY
Larry Williams and Teresa Williams
Reckless Kelly
Marty Stuart and His Fabulous Superlatives
My Morning Jacket
Lukas Nelson

SATURDAY
Anna Moss
Mavis Staples
AJ Lee and Blue Summit
Buddy Miller
John Craigie w/ The Coffis Brothers

SUNDAY
Miko Marks
Darrell Scott String Band w/ Rob Ickes
Jesse Welles
Punch Brothers
Emmylou Harris

Without further ado, here are the 2026 Hardly Strictly Bluegrass Festival SF Journal Awards.

Outstanding Set: Jesse Welles

Sunday was probably my favorite day. It started at the Banjo Stage. Miko Marks had her full band, complete with background singers and sounded great.  Later, we made it over to the Tower of Gold Stage to hear Jesse Welles where we met up with a friend. We had near front row seats close to the stage.

People like to compare Jesse Welles to Bob Dylan as his music is both popular and political. He often rambles on with a sort of stream of conscious, free verse approach to lyrics. While Dylan was often oblique and metaphorical, Jesse Welles is direct and in your face. His songs are often like a collage of news headlines. He does not shy away from using the names of the villains in our midst. The names of Trump and Hegseth make it into his songs some of which are so full of words and move by so fast it can be a bit of information overload. How he flawlessly remember the words to all of his tunes is remarkable. At some point he may write an anthem people will be humming in grocery stores. He is part country, part folk and a lot of rock and roll. His band simply killed it.

Outstanding Soloist: Jesse Welles

We were pretty music blown away by his guitar playing and all-around musical ability.

Best Hair: Jesse Welles

I am not sure what Jesse actually looks like as he has this large mop of brown hair that covers half his face and often wears sunglasses. All you see is his lips and chin. I predict there will be a few folks getting dressed up this Halloween as Jesse Welles. It is but a matter of time.

Best Festival Dog: Large Shepard Mix at the Banjo Stage

I have no idea why anyone would bring a dog to music festival with fifty thousand people. I know that any dog I have owned would go absolutely crazy. But at the Banjo Stage on Friday there were two shepherd-mixes just chilling next to their owners, smiling in the sun.

Best Bluegrass Groove: AJ Lee & Blue Summit

AJ Lee & Blue Summit have been out on the road a lot the last few years. What their original songs lack in depth, they make up for in solid instrumental acumen. It is great that some local Bay Area bands are finally getting the big stages at the festival

Bob Wills “No Mumbling” Award: Jesse Welles

Bob Wills took the approach that if you are playing music keep the customers on the dance floor; do not be mumbling between songs. Jesse Welles kept the tunes going – one after another. It was a tight set.

Best Vocal Harmonies Award: Background Singers for Miko Marks

Miko Marks has an interesting musical story. Getting into the music business later in life, she started gigging in middle age. She embraces her family history in the west. You can read more about it at https://oaklandbca.org/

It is one of those seldom-told stories, about how African Americans are an integral story to the west. Out on the lonely plains and in the mountains more often than not many Black folk were embraced as part of the settler communities once white folk realized that their Black neighbors were indispensable to the community’s survival. For instance, A Black Woman’s West: The Life of Rose B. Gordon by Michael K. Johnson chronicles Rose B. Gordon’s life in small town Montana. There are surely many more similar stories that have never made it to print.

During the festival, many acts paid tribute to Dolly Parton who passed away this year. I have never been a big Country Music fan, save for a few artists and Dolly was never on that list but Dolly sure did have a lot of fans. Miko Marks did an incredible interpretation of I’ll Always Love You.. The background singers were amazing.

Singer that Sounded a Bit Like Willie: Lukas Nelson

Lucas can channel his pops Willie and can sing his songs with that high reedy voice. He is a great musician.

Best Harmonica Playing While Playing Guitar:

Willy Braun on “Wicked Twisted Road”. He really did the most intricate guitar/harmonica playing during the fest. There were a lot of people playing harmonica on a rack this year but Willy’s work was the best.

Great festival! Until next year.

HSB 2026 GALLERY

Past Hardly Strictly Bluegrass Awards – The List is Long

The Death of Expertise: The Campaign against Established Knowledge and Why it Matters – A Review

I don’t know anything and have no perspective, but here is my comment… I feel better now.
Barnstorm in 2013 on the defunct website – Stoke Report

Introduction

The Death of Expertise: The Campaign against Established Knowledge and Why it Matters by Tom Nichols (first edition) from 2018 is a book about how experts no longer have the influence that they did in times past.

Americans have reached the point where  ignorance, especially of anything related to public policy is an actual virtue. To reject the advise of experts is to assert autonomy, a way for Americans  to insulate their increasingly fragile egos from ever being told they are wrong about anything.
The Death of Expertise – by Tom Nichols

I am not an expert or professional book reviewer but I cannot help writing these reviews. They are a way for me to ponder the meaning and ideas of a book. It is simply an exercise in critical thinking.

One thing that you realize from his long resume that besides being a university professor, Tom Nichols is a military expert. I got to know his writing through his many Atlantic articles where he is on staff. His take on the Trump administration and the Commander in Chief is always spot on. It is truly unfortunate that before the current U.S. wars no one consulted Tom Nichols. He surely would have given some sage advise.  He is a throwback Republican – a thinking, well-read Republican. I know not whether he is still registered as a Republican but these days thinking Republicans seem to be in short supply.

Overall the book is a quick-read and in many ways is but a vehicle for Nichols to cathartically gripe about the state of the world. Much of these gripes are things that have arisen since the advent of the internet. Chapter 3: Higher Education: The Customer Is Always Right – Examines how universities treat students as consumers, lowering educational standards definitely is full of antidotes (often funny, sometimes depressing) about how universities have changed. Learning and scholarly pursuits seem to have taken a back seat to coddling the young adults.

College as a client-centered experience caters to adolescents instead of escorting them away from adolescence. Rather than disabusing students of their intellectual solipsism, the modern university ends up reinforcing it.
The Death of Expertise – by Tom Nichols

Indeed, if you have ever seen a college brochure these days, you get the feeling that the prospective students are but customers and of course “the customer is always right.” Fancy dorms. Extra dining options. State-of-the-art gyms. Nichols has been teaching at the university level for decades and has an inside view of this phenomenon.

With these rants and others The Death of Expertise is but a topical book. It is a book that in fifty years will be but a time-capsule of the first part of the twenty-first century and nothing more.

What is not in the book or skimmed over

While Nichols does a great job of explaining many of the current trends such as “confirmation bias,” psychology terms like the Dunning-Kruger Effect and Sturgeon’s Law he does not dig very deeply into why there is a death of expertise. He does give some blame to the internet as often a few Wikipedia pages often makes people feel like they are experts.  For better or worse the internet does  allows just about anyone to express their latest opinions and findings, but the internet is really just one big popularity contest driven by “influencers” and tech companies looking to make a buck.  Being popular and well-liked does not make you and expert. He but lightly touches on this conundrum.

Another area where he treads lightly is in the demise of the journalism profession. Here Nichols does not venture to ask why. Obviously it has to do with the monopolization of the media business. Laws and deregulations that enable corporations to dominate an industry.  The death of small news organizations and reporters. The dismal state of online journalism. This is but briefly mentioned. So called mainstream online journalism will couple articles about pet food next to genocide, weight loss drugs next to serial killers, the latest makeup eyeliner trends next a war in Africa. We seem to have have become normalized to this “expert” editorial style. I find it simply strange and dystopian. These are the “expert” editors? Perhaps it is what Steve Bannon calls “flood the zone.” In actuality he said “flood the zone with shit” but that is a minor detail.

Capitalism and Politics

And what seems to perplex Nichols the most, and where he never ventures is a main reason experts are in decline is because of capitalism. Experts have been in decline for a long time. Fifty years ago oil companies had their very own scientists and experts assess the effect of fossil fuels on the climate. They were overwhelmingly in agreement that fossil fuels would warm the planet and be a problem for humanity. The oil companies ignored their very own experts’ and scientists’  advise.  Al Gore’s The Inconvenient Truth was truly inconvenient so it was ignored. Greed and the all-important dollar won out.

You see this sort of phenomenon whereby experts are ignored in many fields and industries. Recently, in Trump Contagion by Brandy X. Lee you learn that medical organizations such as the American Psychological Association (APA) along with the New York Times put the kabash on a large group of experts in the fields of psychiatry,  law and others.  In 2018 they determined that Donald Trump was seriously mentally ill, unfit to serve as president and an existential threat to humanity.  Even though her earlier book  The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump: 27 Psychiatrists and Mental Health Experts Assess a President  was a best-seller the APA killed her next book Trump Contagion because the pharmaceutical industry, one of their main donors, did not want the book to gain momentum and be taken seriously. The last thing the APA wanted was to be in the crosshairs of Donald Trump so they stifled their experts. What this means is that you have professional organizations ignoring and at times killing the advise of their very own experts. Capitalism and our messed up, mendacious politics is one of the big reason for this death of expertise. As the Paul Simon song goes – “people believe what they want to believe and disregard the rest.”

That is my review and thoughts about The Death of Expertise: The Campaign against Established Knowledge and Why it Matters but as this piece began “I don’t know anything and have no perspective, but here is my comment… I feel better now.” I do know one thing. If I was thinking about starting a war in say Iran, I would definitely want Tom Nichols in the room. He is an expert.

Three Films, The Oscars, Politics, Hollywood and Cultural Myopia

hashtags: #oscars, #brazil, #academy-awards, #movie-review, #dicaprio

In 2025 there were many foreign films that gained a world-wide audience. The Brazilian movie “The Secret Agent” and the Iranian “It Was Just and Accident” were actually nominated for Academy Awards next to the Hollywood blockbusters. In the end, a very flawed Hollywood movie “One Battle After Another,” with a budget of $130–175 million, walked away with all kinds of awards including Best Picture. This short essay examines these three films and reflects on how art has the ability to either illuminate universal truths about the human condition or obfuscate realities and history.

2015 Rio de Janeiro - Ipanema Beach
2015 Rio de Janeiro – Ipanema Beach

We live in a time of rising authoritarianism. In the United States, Donald Trump sees himself more as a king than a president. He thinks he can simply “disappear” his enemies, levy tariffs on a whim, do backdoor deals with oligarchs and CEOs, rape women and not be held accountable, declare wars without senate approval – the list is long. While Iran has been living with kings and ayatollahs for many years, Brazil has had its own history of authoritarianism with a military dictatorship (1964–1985) following a U.S.-backed coup.  The Brazilian movie “The Secret Agent” and the Iranian “It Was Just and Accident” are historical fiction pieces that examine this authoritarianism in their respective countries. The tensions in these movies  between the different sides are very real and the characters embody a complexity that elevates the works to great art.

Three Films, The Oscars, Politics, Hollywood and Cultural Myopia

On the other hand “One Battle After Another,”   is more of a Hollywood fantasy-thriller movie that embraces and perpetuates stereotypes that are  current mainstream media and republican party talking points.  The plot centers around a far-left revolutionary group, the French 75 that uses violence to attempt to forward their political agenda. They rob banks and create havoc in the streets. One cannot help but think that this French 75 is really a stand-in to republicans’ imaginary Antifa. Teyana Taylor plays a convincing Perfidia but her character is pure fantasy.  In the course of human history, a powerful sexy woman of color dominating a testosterone-heavy military goon (Steven J. Lockjaw as played by Sean Penn) is probably something that has literally never happened. More often it is exactly the other way around with men abusing women. The raping and abuse of women has gone on since the beginning of  wars.  The movie also normalizes the military being used against civilians without warrants. Like ICE agents in Minneapolis, we see FBI agents in military helicopters storming the “insurgents.” It is all a bit silly and cartoonish but in our current times has been normalized. Of course, the FBI agents are so incompetent that the person they are looking for in the woods (the cannabis-infused Leonardo DiCaprio) escapes through a tunnel. I mean, really? How stupid are these FBI guys? There are other things that make the film unbelievable (e.g. DiCaprio falling four stories off a building and not breaking a bone.) In the end, his daughter, Charlene escapes from the clutches of the racist white men’s club, takes up the mantel of the revolution and drives off to Oakland – a not too subtle reference to Black Panther party who bore arms and kept watch over the police. In doing so, the movie perpetuates a J. Edgar Hoover paranoid and racist notion that the Black Panthers were all about violence, when in reality they were mostly about uplifting marginalized communities through education and free breakfasts. Film often is a statement about the political atmosphere during their making and “One Battle After Another” is just that. Like a corporate-owned newspaper “One Battle After Another” touches on all the mainstream talking points. For such and expensive film, it actually says very little and what it does say, it does poorly.

Tehran Iran - 1972
Tehran Iran – 1972

In contrast,  the Iranian “It Was Just and Accident” says a lot with very little. The film was made illegally without a permit in Iran by Jafar Panahi and it opens with someone wanting to bury his torturer alive. No big sets and explosions needed – just one vengeful man digging a grave to bury his nemesis in a desert on the edge of town. Through many scenes, involving many people and situations the movie takes on the timeless themes of revenge, forgiveness, marriage, death and birth with the final message of sometimes people simply need a job to survive. People will do atrocious things for money as they have feed their families. In fifty years “It Was Just and Accident” will stand the test of time and will become a classic.

Mosque in Isfahan Iran - 1972
Mosque in Isfahan Iran – 1972

Likewise, “The Secret Agent” combines an amazing script with excellent acting. In the United States the military dictatorships in Brazil seem to be something forgotten but “The Secret Agent” brings this history to life. The amazing cast (this film should have won the Casting Oscar award) was full of both memorable and spot-on characters starting with the lead actor Wagner Moura. Every person seems suited for their characters, especially the hit men who are out to take out Moura’s Armando. From the boss Luciano Chirolli who hires Roney Villela to do the job, who then hires Kaiony Venâncio – it is surely more like how things work in the real world of organized crime. The chain of command is surreptitious with each person covering their asses, hiring an underling and in the process taking a large cut. In the end you get a desperate person to do the dirty deed for very little money. From the beginning scene, a dead person under a piece of cardboard outside a gas station, to the end, the film is a thriller that is entirely believable – save for the hairy leg theme.  No spoilers.

While “One Battle After Another” is about affirming dubious political notions, product placements, stereotypes, misconstrued history and Leonardo DiCaprio dropping the f-bomb over and over (this is quality scriptwriting?), “It Was Just and Accident” and “The Secret Agent” deal successfully with deeper more timeless themes. In the end “It Was Just and Accident” is about forgiveness. With “The Secret Agent” it is about memories, how they are shaped and how technology has such a huge impact on what we remember. The world is presently at war. Eventually, everyone will need to pick up the pieces. Forgiveness and how the history is told will be uppermost in our minds.

 

 

 

Books I Read in 2025

In 2025 most of the books I read were courtesy of the San Francisco Public Library. I read parts of books and checked out books that I was simply curious about. The San Francisco Public Library is an amazing resource. You can even check out vinyl records!

Below is a list of books that I finished. I do this exercise to simply reflect on the previous year.

Books I Read 2025


Crow Planet Essential Wisdom From the Urban Wilderness
Haupt, Lyanda Lynn
New York : Little, Brown and Co., 2009.



The Explosion of Deferred Dreams Musical Renaissance and Social Revolution in San Francisco, 1965-1975
Callahan, Mathew
Oakland, CA : PM Press, [2017]
see review

This is a really interesting book for those interested in San Francisco history.


Eiger Dreams Ventures Among Men and Mountains
Krakauer, Jon
New York, NY : Lyons & Burford, c1990.



The Fifth Risk
Lewis, Michael
New York : W.W. Norton & Company, 2018.

Michael Lewis has spent the last few years investigating what the federal government does. The Fifth Risk illuminates how behind the scenes, dedicated, often eccentric federal employees do jobs that are very important for our safety and also simply to advance pure science.


James A Novel
Everett, Percival
New York : Doubleday, [2024]
see review

The review of James linked above is the most viewed post on this website.


Rasputin The Untold Story
Fuhrmann, Joseph T.
Hoboken, NJ : John Wiley & Sons, c2013.


Bless Me, Ultima
Rudolfo Anaya
TQS Publications 1972


barbariandayscover200
Barbarian Days A Surfing Life
Finnegan, William
New York : Penguin Press, 2015.
see review

Indeed, underestimation is practiced with the greatest aplomb on the North Shore of Oahu. There, a wave must be the size of a small cathedral before locals will call it eight feet.

 

Buzzy Trent, an old-time big wave rider, allegedly said, “Big waves are not measured in feet, but increments of fear.” If he said that, he got it right.
– “Barbarian Days A Surfing Life”


Knoxville: This Obscure Prismatic City
(American Chronicles) Neely, Jack
The History Press; Illustrated edition (November 13, 2009)


Technofeudalism What Killed Capitalism
Varoufakis, Yanis
Brooklyn, NY : Melville House, [2023], ©2023

Indeed we are all serfs in the new economic order, with every social media post adding to the coffers of the the likes of Mark Zuckerberg. Give not your children away to these schmucks!


Notes From Underground
Dostoyevsky, Fyodor
Grand Rapids, Mich. : William B. Eerdmans Pub. Co., 2009.


1984
Orwell, George
San Diego : Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers, [1984], ©1949

It is always good to revisit the dystopian works of the twentieth century. 1984 rings true still.


The Song of the Hawk The Life and Recordings of Coleman Hawkins
Chilton, John
Ann Arbor : University of Michigan Press, c1990.
see review


Walden and Civil Disobedience
Henry David Thoreau
New York : Union Square & Co., 2023.

If simplicity is a virtue, I think that Thoreau has vanished from the American psychique. We are a country where more is better and the accumulation of stuff is really the only virtue.


Tropic of Cancer
Miller, Henry
Mexican Publisher


Stand Still Like the Hummingbird
Miller, Henry
New Directions

“The language of society is conformity; the language of the individual is freedom. Life will continue to be hell as long as the people who make up the world shut their eyes to reality. Switching from one ideology to another is a useless game. Each and every one of us is unique, and must be recognized as such. The least we can say about ourselves is that we are American, or French, or whatever the case may be. We are first of all human beings, different one from another, obliged to live together, to stew in the same pot.”
– Henry Miller from “Stand Still Like the Hummingbird”


Teaching to Transgress Education as the Practice of Freedom
hooks, bell New York : Routledge, 1994.


Abundance
Klein, Ezra
First Avid Reader Press

Good grief! I have no idea why this book was taken seriously. The rose-colored glasses this book takes on the current situation is so devoid of the realities on the ground. It is for those who have this delusional idea that somehow technology will fix all our problems (Bill Gates is in this camp). Climate change is but a bug that we can fix. Miraculously affordable housing will emerge just as long as we get government regulations eradicated. It is as if the authors have no understanding of history.


The World’s Fastest Man the Extraordinary Life of Cyclist Major Taylor, America’s First Black Sports Hero
Kranish, Michael
New York : Scribner, 2019.

Highly recommended book about Marshall “Major” Taylor and a view into the Gilded Age, extraordinary racism, courage and a short period of time when bicycles were the modern thing. The odd fact that the story of Major Taylor is obscure is unfortunate.


The Pirate’s Wife The Remarkable True Story of Sarah Kidd
Geanacopoulos, Daphne Palmer
Toronto : Hanover Square Press, [2022]


King of Kings The Iranian Revolution : A Story of Hubris, Delusion and Catastrophic Miscalculation
Anderson, Scott
First Doubleday hardcover edition
see review


Who Is Government? The Untold Story of Public Service
Lewis, Michael
New York : Riverhead Books, [2025]


The Phantom Tollbooth
Juster, Norton
HarperCollins 1964

Not really a kids book, Norton Juster was a genius.


From Counterculture to Cyberculture
Turner, Fred
Chicago : University of Chicago Press, 2006.

From 2006, From Counterculture to Cyberculture is a bit of love-letter to Stewart Brand and an interesting view of how counter-culture morphed into the techno-libertarian world we live in today. It was written before “social media” and illuminates how the New Communalists of the early 1970s morphed into a notion of a digital utopia where people became one and could communicate for the good of all humankind. Enter, Newt Gingrich and an ethos of libertarian deregulation and we have the current world we live in today. It briefly goes into the Telecommunications Act of 1996 but does not even mention the Digital Millennium Copyright Act – DMCA of 1998.

While Tanner’s thesis is correct, the book ignores a lot of the events and forces that were going on at the time and instead redundantly drives home the point that the people who drove VW Westphalia’s in the seventies are now surely driving Tesla’s and living in gated communities, counting their millions.

King of Kings: The Iranian Revolution – A Review and Reflections

King of Kings: The Iranian Revolution: A Story of Hubris, Delusion and Catastrophic Miscalculation is the full title of a book by Scott Anderson published in 2025.  The gist of the book is that the United States, distracted by the Soviet Union and the cold war, overly compartmentalized in its state department and spy networks, did not take the religious fundamentalism that was growing in Iran seriously.  Few people in the state department or even at the embassy spoke Farsi. Not many were in the smaller towns and countryside. Important warnings were ignored. Crucial reports where just filed away. While the book looks at the history of Iran and things like the 1953 coup, it mostly focuses on the leadup to the 1979 revolution. Three key sources are referenced throughout the book: Farah Pahlavi, Michael Metrinko and National Security Council officer Gary Sick.  Through this lens you see clearly the catastrophic miscalculations of the U.S. that lead to the fall of shah and the Iran hostage crisis. There are some juicy moments like when President Carter visited Iran in the 1970s and brought Dizzy Gillespie and Sarah Vaughan along for entertainment. Their improvisations and informality were perplexing to the stiff Shah and gave Gary Sick insights into the monarch he was dealing with. Additionally, Michael Metrinko who was one of the hostages provides some interesting and humorous  observations along the way.

“By my count I worked with nineteen different American generals over there,” Metrinko observed in the autumn of 2021, shortly after the American forces had abandoned Afghanistan to the Taliban, “but at this point I’d be very hard-pressed to tell you which one was the dumbest.”

When it gets to 1978 the book moves slowly and recounts the tense daily events leading up to the storming of the U.S Embassy and the Iran hostage crisis. The details and complexity of the situation are well-researched and conveyed. Eventually, you learn that the shah, battling cancer, leaves Tehran with his family – the shah in the cockpit of a Boeing 707, piloting the jetliner out of Iran. The book is quite the page turner and begs the question that if the state department was so incompetent then, it must be even more a disaster today. 5 stars.

King of Kings: The Iranian Revolution: A Story of Hubris, Delusion and Catastrophic Miscalculation
Publisher ‏ : ‎ Doubleday
Publication date ‏ : ‎ August 5, 2025
Language ‏ : ‎ English
Print length ‏ : ‎ 512 pages

NOTE: The author of this review lived in Tehran from 1970 to 1972, attended fourth and fifth grade at Iranzamin international school, and while he does not speak much Farsi, he does remember a few swear words that he learned by listening to frustrated Tehran cab drivers. The photo above is indeed from the author’s stamp collection from that era.

RELATED POST: Later, while in high school back in the United States, he questioned a United States senator about the situation in Iran. The senator seemed a bit stumped by the question. In a way, it foretold the disaster about to unfold.

 I had always wondered how it was possible for the two disparate worlds to get along and how the meeting of the West with the Persian world would work out in the end. Stylish woman getting off the plane from shopping sprees in Paris, wearing the latest fashions  in the same streets with Muslim women in traditional chadors.  How is this possible?

Dear Senator, I have a question

 

 

Hardly Strictly 2025 SF Journal Awards

Hardly Strictly Bluegrass 2025 took place in Golden Gate Park on Fri, Oct 3, 2025 – Sun, Oct 5, 2025. It is a free event and you can learn more about it at https://hardlystrictlybluegrass.com/.

The weather during the festival in 2025 was quite pleasant with light winds out of the west and mostly clear skies. The temperature for most days was around 70 degrees Fahrenheit. By Friday, the warm temperatures and sunny skies ruled. Unlike years before, when you could wander in from anywhere, the festival has entrances and a security checks. Fortunately the entire festival was peaceful.

There are basically two approaches to HSB. One is to travel light and get in as many acts in as possible, roaming from one stage to the next. The other is to bring a tarp or blankets, chairs and a small cooler full of food and drinks and park at a single stage. If you get to the festival early, it is easy to get a great spot. This year we did a bit of both. I had family and friends in town – great times Phil, Judy, Andrea, Patricia and Steve! Thanks for coming to the festival!

Without further ado, here are the 2025 Hardly Strictly Bluegrass Festival SF Journal Awards.

Outstanding Set: SAMARA JOY and Her Killer Band

Samara Joy came with an outstand band and delivered a phenomenal set. Her band was alto sax, tenor sax, trumpet and trombone, piano, bass and drums. They played mostly standards at very fast tempos and each solo got two choruses. No eight bar breaks for this band. Near the end the trombone and trumpet traded solos. Alexandra Ridout did an excelent job coming in on trumpet. The arrangements were cleaver and punchy and the phrasing and articulations were spot on.
https://www.samarajoy.com/

Trumpet: Alexandra Ridout
Trombone: Donavan Austin
Saxophone: David Mason (alto sax/flute), Kendric McCallister (tenor sax)
Piano: Connor Rohrer
Bass: Felix Moseholm
Drums: Evan Sherman

Outstanding Soloist: Trombone Player Donavan Austin in SAMARA JOY’s Killer Band

It is a bit odd for an outstanding soloist at a bluegrass festival to go to a trombonist, however I do believe that Mister Bill Monroe would probably not argue with me if he had heard Donavan. A wonderful synthesis of Slide Hampton and Frank Rosolino. Look out! Donavan can play!

Best Cumbia Groove: CHUCK PROPHET AND HIS CUMBIA SHOES

Chuck Prophet is an interesting guy who brought together an eclectic band of Latino players. His stream of conscious lyrics float over various cumbia and rock grooves and along with their coordinated brown cumbia outfits it all just works. Chuck is a fun guitar player to listen to, often venturing into sonic landscapes while the other guitar player rips on the metal licks. Excellent set.
https://chuckprophet.com/

Chuck Prophet

Best Bluegrass Groove:  DAN TYMINSKI BAND

Dan Tyminsky is the guy who sang “I am a Man of Constant Sorrow” for George Clooney on the movie “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” Of course they did sing this song and all was well. Solid band that at one point invited Sam Bush up on stage to add to the party.

Bob Wills “No Mumbling” Award: CIMAFUNK

Bob Wills was the leader of Bob Wills and the Texas Playboys, who some say invented Western Swing. One thing Bob did not like was band leaders that mumbled on the mic between songs. He was of the the belief that people came to hear you play and dance not to hear you talk. He played his sets with songs back to back, never pausing to reflect, always keeping the couples on the dance floor. Bob probably would have enjoyed Cimafunk, the powerhouse international band (mostly from Cuba) who played some funky grooves, almost reminiscent of Tower of Power at one point. They played one song after another. Unlike some of the country acts that told stories that were difficult to hear and attempted to tune their guitars between songs, Cimafunk just busted into the next groove.

Best Vocal Harmonies Award: I’M WITH HER

I’m With Her are three outstanding female musicians who can both play and sing – Sara Watkins, Sarah Jarosz, and Aoife O’Donovan. Their sound brings to mind Crosby, Stills and Nash in their early days with beautiful three part harmonies. If they pass through town, buy the good seats.
https://imwithherband.com/

I’m With Her

Most Energetic Show: CIMAFUNK

In terms of total calories burned, Cimafunk won this award. No contest

HSBG 2025 – Cimafunk

Up and Coming Artist Award:  KAIA KATER

Kaia Kater played on the Horseshoe Stage which was a cute little stage on top of a hill. I really enjoyed her clawhammer banjo playing and interesting song writing.

Best Sign On a Backpack Award: GUY WITH CLEAR BACKPACK

Fuck the NRA for making me Buy This

HSBG 2025 - Fuck the NRA For Making Me Need to Buy This
Fuck the NRA For Making Me Need to Buy This

SURF REPORT & WEATHER

This report would not be complete without a surf round up. A large short period wind swell which was unruly and unsurfable was at Ocean Beach on Friday. This gave way to some shoulder high glassiness and outstanding surf by Sunday. This surf continued on for a few days until the fog rolled back in.

Band We Listened to:

ANDERSON EAST
SHAWN COLVIN
THE WAR & TREATY
NITTY GRITTY DIRT BAND

JEFF TWEEDY
SAMARA JOY
CIMAFUNK
DAN TYMINSKI BAND
KAIA KATER
SAMARA JOY

CHUCK PROPHET AND HIS CUMBIA SHOES
NICK LOWE & LOS STRAITJACKETS
I’M WITH HER
EVOLFO
LUCINDA WILLIAMS
ALAN SPARHAWK w/ TRAMPLED BY TURTLES
EMMYLOU HARRIS

Hardly Strictly Bluegrass 2025 – Preview

HSB 25

Hardly Strictly Bluegrass 2025 will take place in Golden Gate Park on Fri, Oct 3, 2025 – Sun, Oct 5, 2025. It is a free event and you can learn more about it at https://hardlystrictlybluegrass.com/.

I have been attending the Hardly Strictly Bluegrass festival for many years and even do a sort of review and give out awards. It is all in good fun and looking back over it I did notice something. This year there are fewer headline acts and not many bands from New Orleans. In the past years there were big name artists like Steely Dan, Boz Skaggs, Rickie Lee Jones, Asleep at the Wheel, Elvis Costello, Mavis Staples, Jon Batiste, Alan Toussaint to name but a few. This year it seems to be more of the standard bluegrass people with a sprinkling of alt-rock, country, singer-songwriter thing thrown in. But it is all good. Who can complain about a free music festival! One thing for sure about the festival is that you always discover someone that you never knew about that knocks your socks off.

I am looking forward to a few bands I have heard before: Samara Joy is a beautiful singer and Cimafunk is a young Cuban band that is forging new terrain. A few bucket list bands like Nitty Gritty Dirt Band who hopefully will sing Mr. Bojangles and new-comers like Max Gomez. The adventure starts Friday. Pace yourself!

AFTER HOURS IN SAN FRANCISCO

If you still have some energy after you flew in from out of town, and you want to hear some local players, maybe have a beer, here are my suggestions. These are all slanted towards the San Francisco jazz scene in town.

The Royal Cuckoo Organ Lounge
3202 Mission St at Valencia – Music from 8-11pm
Often some of the best working jazz players in town. The place is small and intimate and very old school spinning the vinyl on the breaks.

Keys Bistro
For another outstanding jazz a good spot in North Beach is Keys Bistro 498 Broadway. Excellent food at the venue and many excellent restaurants nearby.

Madrone Art Bar
And if you are still going on Sunday, I highly recommend the session at Madrone Art Bar not far from Golden Gate Park. Sunday B3 Sessions Hosted by Adam Shulman and Mike Olmos Swinging soul jazz with a jam session to follow 9pm-Close No Cover
500 Divisadero Street.

Past SF Journal HSB Awards

The Song of Hawk – The Life and Recordings of Coleman Hawkins – A Review

The Song of Hawk – The Life and Recordings of Coleman Hawkins is a biography by John Chilton of Coleman Hawkins, one of the most influential tenor saxophonists and musicians of the twentieth century. John Chilton was an English trumpet player and working jazz musician, who has methodically chronicled every recording session that Coleman Hawkins ever played; this was a lot of sessions. Interspersed with the details of these sessions, are life events, gigs, travels and various quotes from musicians and others that give light to Hawkins and the environment he was living in.

Coleman Hawkins was born in 1904 so most of the recordings were 78s. The book chronicles each of these recordings as a timeline of Hawkins’ life. How Chilton got his hands on these records in unknown and unfortunately the book does not have a discography.  The book does gets a bit lugubrious at times with the author’s impressions of the various soloists and recording qualities, but it is for true fans who do not mind the details.  For this reader, it was about finding needles in the haystack. Hawkins indeed played and recorded with John Coltrane, Duke Ellington and Thad Jones. These are surely interesting listens that I was unaware of and want to pursue. For many years he took Thelonious Monk under his wing.  Many people asked him why he used Monk, who’s playing was unorthodox, when he could have hired a “real” piano player. Hawkins knew genius when he heard it. It is interesting to muse how differently Monk’s career would have been without Hawkins.

While many biographies delve into the personal, The Song of Hawk – The Life and Recordings of Coleman Hawkins, mostly stays away from Hawkins’ personal and family life. The one aspect where this is not true is the insane quantity of liquor consumed. Coleman liked his scotch and brandy.

We just happened to be living in the same hotel in Nottingham, only living about three doors apart. So Fats would bring by my breakfast every morning – a glass of Scotch, full glass, a water glass of whiskey. You see that is the way we drank. It would take me an hour to drink a glass of scotch; he’d drink it in two minutes, straight down, just like he was drinking water. He was a big drinker and a big eater. Yeah, Fats was something else.
Hawkins reflecting on a stint with Fats Waller at a European hotel


We got along nicely. He was such a wonderful person. I couldn’t believe that anyone could drink so much alcohol and that it would have so little effect on him.
Arthur Briggs

But what was amazing about Hawkins was even though he smoked two packs of cigarettes a day and drank all that booze, people generally found him to be a great guy. While he was in many ways a very private person and did not say much, he did often help out younger players and talent.

First, he taught me to put expression into singing ballads, and he did it saying, ‘Carp, if you’re putting a song across, you’ve got to regard it as if you are making love. You greet the song, then you slowly get closer to it, caressing it, kissing it, and finally making love to it, and when you bring your performance to a climax you don’t just end it there and then, you have to be just as tender as you were when you began, so that the audience feels the flow of your expression and they end up peaceful and satisfied.’
Thelma Carpenter

From 1934 to 1939, Hawkins lived in Europe where he played long residencies in various clubs and hotels. Sometimes he was backed up by other Americans but more often by local European players. At one point he took to the slopes.

Hawkins’s success in Switzerland were just as great as those he had enjoyed in other parts of Europe. During the winter of 1935-36 he worked in St Moritz (where he learned how to ski)… his main base was Zurich.

St. Moritz - Wikipedia
St. Moritz – Wikipedia

If there is ever a movie made of his life, the film should start with Coleman Hawkins skiing in the Alps, Hawk bundled up, smoking a cigarette, looking out at the sublime mountains, ready to head down the mountain. Needless to say. Mr. Hawkins, while being a fine saxophone player, could also be known as an early predecessor to the modern ski bum. I have a feeling he probably mostly enjoyed the apre ski.

He was amused and sometimes vexed, when local jazz critics praised only black musicians, automatically excluding white performers from any listing of  favorites. Having always kept an open mind when listening to jazz musicians, he had difficulty in making Europeans understand that there were some white jazz musicians he genuinely enjoyed. “After all. I played with Benny Goodman and all of them and I didn’t know any clarinet player that played more than Benny.”

In 1939 he returned to the United States. In that same year he recorded the ballad Body and Soul which was a big hit and set the stage for the modernism on 52nd Street – tritone substitutions, irregular measured phrases, harmony derived from the vocabulary of Ravel and other impressionists, complex polyrhythms and ridiculously fast tempos which soon challenged the pop tune and riff-based music of the big band era.

It is always important to note that Coleman Hawkins idea of a good time at home was kicking back and listening to classical music. He had a vast collection of operas and symphonies on vinyl and a state-of-the-art high-fi. People commented that when they visited him in his apartment they would find him in a comfortable chair with an opera playing on the hi-fi and tears streaming down his face.

Competitive to the end, you get a real sense of this with a recollection from Cannonball Adderley.

A young tenor player was complaining to me that Coleman Hawkins made him nervous; I told him Hawkins was suppose to make him nervous for forty years.
Julian “Cannonball” Adderley

hawk-record-smWhile The Song of Hawk – The Life and Recordings of Coleman Hawkins is a welcome addition to the genre of jazz history, one can get a very good idea of the life of Coleman Hawkins by simply reading the liner notes by Dan Morgenstern of The Hawk Flies which won a Grammy award for liner notes. Morgenstern knew Hawkins well and later in his life helped him get gigs. There was a heartfelt personal relationship there which is non-existent  in The Song of Hawk – The Life and Recordings of Coleman Hawkins. The Song of Hawk digs very deep in a very methodical way into the life of Hawkins in a very detached way. I doubt anyone will take the time to write it again. It is a welcome addition to understanding this music called jazz.

The Hawk Flies reissue with Dan Morgenstern liner notes
The Hawk Flies reissue with Dan Morgenstern liner notes

CODA

When I was fifteen years old, living in Madison, Wisconsin, one summer I went out riding my bike looking for a job. I road down State Street and outside a French restaurant, The Ovens of Brittany, I saw two cooks on break outside. They were hanging out on a stoop, and as people do in the restaurant business, having a smoke break. I asked them if there was any work. After a few moments they asked me if I wanted to clean up and paint the staircase behind them. Somehow a bucket of molasses had been kicked down the stairs. It had splattered everywhere – on the carpeting, against the door, on the walls. We must have agreed on a wage and I then commenced with a bucket of hot water, rags, mop and a sponge. When I had finished later that day, I went to pick up my pay. They were happy with my work and asked what my plans were for the evening. I said that I was free, to which they asked if I wanted to wash dishes. The dishwasher had called in sick. I told them that it sounded great but that I would need to call my mother.  And so ensued my decades-long career in the restaurant industry.

The Ovens of Brittany dishroom was in the basement of an old corner building that was probably from the last century. Every ten of fifteen minutes a tub of dishes would make its way down via a manual dumbwaiter. The people who worked at the restaurant were mostly college students, so at a young age I was conversing about adult topics with people five or ten years my senior. From a Jewish guy from New York I learned about the term anti-Semitism. You grew up fast in those days.

With the tips that I made as a dishwasher I would mosey on down to the record stores on State Street and buy vinyl, mostly jazz cut-outs. One of those records was The Hawk Flies a remastered Milestone reissue of various dates. On that record are amazing sidemen – J.J. Johnson, Hank Jones, Nat Adderley, Idrees Sulieman, Max Roach, Thelonious Monk. The sound of Coleman Hawkins and that sophisticated modern music coming out of New York City was the perfect sound track for the feeling I had after a six hour dish shift. I was hooked.

Great Highway: Journey to the Soul of San Francisco Surfing – A Movie Review

Great Highway traces the roots of Bay Area surfing and explores the changes that time reveals. The history is told by those who lived it in the freezing cold Bay Area conditions. Starring Jack O’Neill, Jack LaLanne, Fred Van Dyke and Michael Ho. The local surfers of Northern California are full of character, and offer their own perspectives on the history and the future of surfing.

Great Highway: Journey to the Soul of San Francisco Surfing is a documentary film about surfing in San Francisco. You can read more about the movie at  https://www.greathighwaymovie.com.

What makes the movie all the more valuable and entertaining is that it is not just about surfing, but really about the history of San Francisco, especially on the west side of town. It goes back to the nineteenth century and takes a geographical perspective on Yerba Buena. Eventual, it focuses on what was called The Outside Lands, the sandy desolate place out by the ocean that is now called the Sunset District. We get a view of the various scrappy settlements that took hold out there including Carville, which was made of reused abandoned horsecars (horse-drawn trolleys) and, later, cable cars for housing and public buildings. You get to romp through the period of the heyday of Adolph Sutro’s Sutro Baths and the massive  Fleishhacker Pool where now the San Francisco Zoo is located. Eventually the salt water of the ocean had its way and these public places are long gone, though there is still a good left exactly where the Fleishhacker Pool bathhouse once was and old timers still call it Fleishhacker’s. The bathhouse eventually did burn down.

The actual Great Highway was built in the 1929.  The movie then romps through grainy footage and interviews of the various surfers who braved the cold water and surfed without wetsuits on crude, homemade boards. It highlights the rebel nature of these early surfers. a persona that interestingly has sort of disappeared as surfing has become more mainstream. The audacity of people like Fred Van Dyke, Bill Hickey, Bill Bergerson and Rod Lundquist to name but a few who broke trail, surfing without wetsuits in the frigid Ocean Beach waters. The movie goes on to talk about the wool sweaters, the fires on the beach and Jack O’Neil inventing the modern wetsuit. The movie has a very raw, low-budget appeal, just like the early days of the sport. It was timely that the film came out in 2017 as many of the old timers that were interviewed have now passed. Their recollections and candor are awe-inspiring. A great movie for people of all ages.

FIVE STARS *****

There are a few ways to see the movie. You can stream on Amazon Prime for a fee or buy the DVD at https://www.greathighwaymovie.com/product-page/great-highway

DIRECTOR
MARK GUNSON

EDITOR
MARK RUEGG

PRODUCER
KRISTA HOWELL

NARRATOR

JIM NORTON

MUSIC FROM
WRITTEN BY

MARK GUNSON
JIM NORTON
MERMEN
KATDELIC
TIM FLANNERY & The Lunatic Fringe

Barbarian Days: A Surfing Life by William Finnegan – A Review

These novels will give way, by and by, to diaries or autobiographies – captivating books, if only a man knew how to choose among what he calls his experiences that which is really his experience, and how to record truth truly.”
– Ralph Waldo Emerson

barbariandayscover200William Finnegan’s – Barbarian Days: A Surfing Life is a memoir. It is mostly a true story of a life where the common thread is surfing. Finnegan grew up in Southern California and Hawaii and at one point when he was just a grom the waves were not far from his family’s humble house near Diamond Head, Hawaii. He took to surfing at a very early age and though he does not admit it, became a big wave surfer, riding huge waves on the North Shore of Oahu, Ocean Beach in San Francisco, discovering a wave in Fiji and later in life, Portugal.  When he was a young teenager he began to experience the power of the ocean.

 

I was shaken to the core by the sound of the waves detonating a few yards behind me. I was convinced that if I had been caught inside I would have died.
William Finnegan at fourteen surfing the Rice Bowl in Hawaii

For some inexplicable reason, he kept coming back to these harrowing experiences.  He seems to have remembered the minute details of various rides from previous decades were he thought the end was near. Captivating read indeed, and much of it surely somewhere near the truth.

The book is a romp through various times in his life. It is a very fun read not just because of the surfing tales but it gives a window into a time in history when people had the ability to be very mobile, flying to faraway lands, but at the same time communications back home did not exist. A telegram now and then. Regular letter writing but making a call on a phone was far too expensive and not common. People out in the world traveling used random message boards, taping hand writing messages in often feeble attempts to contact others.

In the end, I teamed up with other Westerners, bribed some Bulgarian border guards, made my way through the Balkans and over the Alps and, with the help of an American Express office message board in Munich, found [his girlfriend] Caryn in a campground south of the city. She seemed fine.
William Finnegan at nineteen bumming around Europe

For this reader, the chapters where he travels around the world for a few years chasing waves with his friend Bryan is truly amazing. With nautical charts they head off to the South Pacific and discover a phenomenal wave in Fiji, unknown to the world but for a few. Now the spot is an expensive surfing resort destination. A year in Australia surfing and working odd jobs, searching for waves. Buying a beater car and driving it clear across the country, always a bit concerned if it would overheat or the next day would even start. Such road trips are times when living in the moment seems to take precedence. They seem to be not so much in nature but a part of nature.

Then there is the peculiar way that wave size is measured. While this may not be of interest to people who do not surf, it gets pretty funny.

Indeed, underestimation is practiced with the greatest aplomb on the North Shore of Oahu. There, a wave must be the size of a small cathedral before locals will call it eight feet.

 

Buzzy Trent, an old-time big wave rider, allegedly said, “Big waves are not measured in feet, but increments of fear.” If he said that, he got it right.

Barbarian Days – A Surfing Life is a very fun read, especially if you enjoy travelogues, you are a surfer or just love the outdoors. There may be times when the author delves into the finer points of a two wave hold-down, or the advantages of a certain fin set up or length of board.  This talk must be a bit perplexing and perhaps a bit tedious to the non-surfer. One thing that Finnegan claims is that it is just about impossible to get really good at surfing  if you pick it up later in life. I am living proof of this theory and would agree.

Getting old as a surfer, I’d heard it said, was just a long, slow, humiliating process of becoming a kook again.

CODA:EVERY SURFER HAS A STORY
I started surfing at the age of thirty-five, an age far too advanced to every actually get really good at the sport. I mostly do it for the exercise, be with friends and to commune with nature. It is amazing the wildlife you see out in the water. I regularly surf with dolphins and certain times of the year there are whales within twenty feet.

Paul Lyons surfing Ocean Beach - March 2008
Paul Lyons surfing Ocean Beach in his late forties – March 2008. This session was complete luck. I remember paddling out with a board that my friend had found while on the job cleaning out student housing. I found a channel right away and caught three really nice waves. This was a rare session. I have always been a bit of a kook. – Photo by Doug Oakley

I remember the thrill of the first time I took off on a head-high wave and made it. I also remember the first time I took off on big wave on a long period swell. The waves were overhead at Ocean Beach back in the days when you would sometimes be the only person in the water. It did actually get lonely out there.  I went right, stayed high on the shoulder and remember just flying down the wave faster than I had ever surfed. I had never ridden a wave with such power. I also remember a day when my surf buddies and I when out at Ocean Beach and the waves were big but seemed at the time nothing scary. I had only been surfing a few years. We made it out past the shore-break and white water only to discover that the swell, in the course of the next hour, had increased quickly. A huge set came and we tossed our boards and dove underneath. I broke my leash, lost my board which eventually washed into shore. We both paddled in a bit terrified by the whole ordeal. I pledged to never to do that again. It scared the bejesus out of me. Later I saw the buoys from when we were out. It  had jumped up to 11 feet at 19 seconds. Big waves. That’s my one captivating story and it is all true.

William Finnegan lives in Manhattan and the end of the book loses the wild adventure of earlier years. Parents die. He becomes a father. Life becomes more urban. In his seventies he must still be a really good surfer as he surfs off of Long Island in the winter and will chase waves in the summer and even during  hurricanes.

For those who love the adventure of youth and want to escape into that magical time of traveling before the internet, I highly recommend William Finnegan’s – Barbarian Days: A Surfing Life is a Pulitzer Prize winning memoir.

5 Stars

“James” the Novel – A Review

James is a novel by author Percival Everett and is based on Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain. It tells the story in the first person not from the character Huck but through the enslaved person Jim. Huck Finn is a classic work of American literature that everyone has heard of but as I am finding few people have actually read. Ernest Hemingway is quoted as saying “all modern American literature comes from one book by Mark Twain called Huckleberry Finn.” A few years ago I wanted to revisit this Twain classic. Thinking I could pick up a copy at a local Goodwill I found myself out of luck. I did find one eventually and when I read the introduction I soon realized I had picked up a sanitized, censored version. I had purchased the 2011 edition of the book, published by NewSouth Books. This version replaced the term “nigger” with “slave” (not even enslaved person) throughout the book. I am sure that Twain would have not approved as he got bent out of shape when his editors simply changed his punctuation.

But the truth is, that when a Library expels a book of mine and leaves an unexpurgated Bible lying around where unprotected youth and age can get hold of it, the deep unconscious irony of it delights me and doesn’t anger me.
– Letter to Harriet Whitmore, 7 February 1907

Huck Finn Illustration
Huck Finn Illustration

In any event, Huck Finn has been banned from the beginning.  I did eventually purchase the original Huck Finn, complete with illustrations. This was the version Mark Twain approved. It is always best to read the original.

Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is a complicated tale that brings up many timeless themes. It makes perfect sense for Everett to use Huck Finn as a springboard for a reimagining of this classic. James  tells the story of Huck Finn through the eyes and ears of Jim; in this way he is pulling one on Twain by making a “stretcher” out of his “stretcher.” Additionally Everett goes a step further than Twain and allows the character Jim to not just be freed but to become empowered.  James like Huck Finn challenges assumptions about race, sex, gender and identity and in the end through a combination of education, courage, reason and the performative, James finds agency by embracing the ideals of The Enlightenment. James is a book about the “American dream.”

In order to get the most out of James it is best to have first read a few books that are referenced otherwise these references will make no sense.  Start with the short novella Candide: or, The Optimist (1759)  by Voltaire (it is around 100 pages). Like Huck Finn this book was banned and Voltaire did spend time in prison for his writings. Candide is a bit like a comic book in that it moves very fast – there is sex, rapes and violence, gold and jewels. Like Huck Finn it is really for adults. Characters and places from Candide make their way into James.  Of course the next step is to read Huck Finn – the original version with all the bad words. Take your time.

A major theme throughout James is the performative and the anxiety that surrounds identity. In modern times this has been often called code-switching. Jim has to be careful that he does not slip out of the language of being a slave and give away that he can read and write. Of course he pulls it off mostly until at a crucial point in the book (which I will not spoil). An important thing about this code-switching is that it is handed down through generations with the elders teaching their youth how to speak and act like a slave as a means of survival. In modern language, this is perhaps a psychological aspect of what is called systemic racism. You also have a few characters who’s sex or gender are misidentified – Doris and Sammy. This is not thoroughly explained but surely has to do with black people being controlled and abused by their owners. Interestingly, the people concerned are so abused they simply accept their lot in life. Of course the King and the Duke are all about code-switching and impersonating royalty. I think it was a missed opportunity that James does not play around more with these two characters as Twain did, revealing the arrogance, corruption and incompetence of royalty. How soon we forget.

In James, the historical characters Voltaire and Locke enter the novel though Jim’s dreams. The first time is soon after he is bitten by a snake and delirious. In this way, history becomes surreal and less believable than the fiction – we only see historical figures in dreams. Jim’s dream-induced conversations with Voltaire are brief but we get references to Westphalia and the notion of “tending your garden” and near the end Cunégonde, the love interest of Candide. Besides references to these themes the philosophical themes that Voltaire brings up in his work are not ventured into. There is no Professor Pangloss and his dogmatic “best of all possible worlds” mantra. By the time James reunites with his wife Sadie and daughter, the Voltaire references are long gone. Unlike  Cunégonde, Sadie has not lost her charm and is not irritating to be around. And unlike Candide who’s identity is a constant, Jim becomes James and this identity is reinforced with the notion that you claim your identity through courage and the performative. James discards that layer of his self that is disenfranchising. If you no longer speak with the diction of a slave, then you are no longer a slave.

Race in America has a complicated history and Everett helps to illuminate this complexity not dumb it down or simplify it.  In the end, James does begin to live his dream of freedom and is empowered by his literacy and the ideals of The Enlightenment that all men are created equal. As the plot twists and turns, by the end James is not anything like Huck Finn. We find ourselves back in Hannibal then another city with Jim looking for his wife and family on a “breeder farm.” Good grief! Things move quickly and become a bit like a Cohen Brothers thriller movie with lots of violence and fireworks. It is probably a good idea to read the book now. It is a thrilling page-turner and James will be in theaters soon.